Category — Shopper Marketing
Digital Empathy
Listen closely to real people to develop emotional insights. By Whitney Browne. I recently sat through a series of focus groups in which a broad cross-section of consumers in Atlanta and Los Angeles spoke about their relationships with technology, particularly their mobile devices. The participants ranged in age from early twenties to late sixties, and they came from a wide array of socio-economic backgrounds.
While the various groups were organized by demographics, I noticed a startling theme that wended its way through all groups. This theme manifested itself in varying ways — depending on who was sharing — but the message was quite clear: we have an uneasy relationship with the new marvels of technology that more and more have come to dominate our time and attention.
One woman in particular said something that struck me. We were talking about mobile devices and she said, “I had a touchscreen phone for two days. I loved it but I saw myself going down a dark path, so I returned it and went back to BlackBerry” … read >>
May 16, 2012 Comments
Divining Insights
Let your creative people take a bath in data. By Beth Ann Kaminknow. Data, and its sister, analytics, are the new sexy in advertising and marketing. Every agency and company now has an in-house data and analytics practice. It is blasphemy even to think of making any business move without the aid of sifting through mounds of data, given its ability to lead to better (more accurate) decision-making.
In today’s technologically-advanced environment, the ability to capture and report data is much more accessible. With increased data-processing capabilities, we can build more complex models that can churn out more complex data. Both descriptive and predictive analytics can now do an exceptional job of uncovering the answers to “who, what, where, when, how and why.”
So, with all of this data at our fingertips, you would also expect that we are becoming smarter, more efficient, and productive marketers. Perhaps in some instances this is true, but in many cases we have yet to optimize a data-driven creative process. We are overflowing with data, but there is a critical missing link … read >>
May 14, 2012 Comments
Test & Learn
Packaged-goods brands must change their culture to capitalize on digital. By Seth Diamond. Much to the contrary of current belief, there is little connection between shopper influence and “liking” a brand on Facebook. Even when you entice with a coupon, or throw in a branded, exclusive piece of swag to “buy” a like, the consumer experience pretty much stops there. Frankly, it’s unknown whether any of the tactics like Foursquare, Pinterest or QR codes are really moving your business.
If that’s the case, why invest in them without understanding if and how they will enhance purchase behavior? Culturally, packaged-goods brands need to change how they approach digital marketing. Facebook is not a magic bullet for all of your marketing experiences; it’s tougher than that. Chasing a new digital tool just because a competitor is using it doesn’t work either — not without insights, analysis and an understanding of how that tool is used by shoppers.
To fully embrace digital marketing, packaged-goods marketers need to change their organization’s culture to one of test and learn. Secondly, they must position digital tools to be a solution to a program and let the metrics guide them to those marketing approaches that have earned the right to scale up for success …
read >>
May 9, 2012 Comments
Priceonomics
How we feel about ourselves has a lot to do with the prices we are willing to pay, reports the Economist (5/5/12). Ayelet Gneezy and a team of researchers at the University of California conducted a series of studies suggesting that “a desire to think of yourself as a good person” can drive how much you’ll pay for something. Their research, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, also found “that allowing people to name their own price may result in fewer sales than the old-fashioned approach of simply setting a single price for everybody.” One experiment involved “53,000 customers of a theme park, who were photographed while riding a rollercoaster.” All customers were allowed to name their own price for the photo, but some were told that half of the price “would be donated to a children’s charity.”
Interestingly, the price offered by those giving half to charity was five times that of those who were simply asked to name their own price. However, “only half as many people” in the charity group chose to buy a photo at all. The researchers say that “the two results are linked: because the ‘right’ price for the charity-and-photo combination was felt to be much higher, a significant number of people preferred not to buy at all than to damage their self-image by offering a miserly price, and, by extension, a tight-fisted donation to a deserving cause.”
A second experiment involved buying photographs from a boat ride — with the price set at $15 for one group, $5 for another and “name your own price” for the third. All three groups were told that the normal price was $15. Demand rose at the $5 price point and fell among the “name your price” group. The researchers say this is because “an overly low price can feel unpleasantly parsimonious.” In a third experiment, restaurant patrons were allowed to pick the price, but some had to pay in public while others settled up in private. Those who paid in private “chose to pay more, on average, than those who paid in public.” Researchers conclude that this means “it is your conscience that prods you to be generous, as opposed to pressure from your peers.”
May 9, 2012 Comments
Got Smarts?
A roundtable discussion on consumer and shopper insights, with Stephanie Cota of Mattel Brands, Hermann Deininger of Adidas, Sally Grimes of Newell Rubbermaid, Alfredo Martel of Caribou Coffee and Kevin Lane Keller of Dartmouth College.
What is the hardest thing to get right with consumers today?
Stephanie Cota: One of the hardest things to get right with consumers today is message authenticity. Consumers are very smart, and they are very pressed for time. They are increasingly intolerant of messages that are over-complicated or over-clever.
As a consumer, I also become challenged when watching a clever commercial but can’t necessarily tell you what the brand or product was. That said, some brands have done a great job of staying true to their message, both at a mass and a class level.
From a mass perspective, Campbell Soup and Kraft Macaroni and Cheese do a really great job of staying true to who they are. In the class space, Louis Vuitton and Manolo Blahnik are authentic with their messages. Staying true to your message, but delivering it in fresh, compelling ways, is one of the more challenging things that we do as marketers … read >>
May 7, 2012 Comments
The Hub Top 20
Growth and diversity power the next great phase of shopper-marketing excellence. By Dan Flint. Welcome to the 2012 and fifth annual Hub Top 12 report on shopper marketing excellence that, thanks to industry growth, has now become the Hub Top 20! We want to thank all who participated in the survey this year and especially those who took the time to add insightful comments.
The University of Tennessee is pleased to continue the tradition of tracking shopper-marketing excellence, initiated and created by Hoyt & Company and The Hub Magazine in 2008. The intent of this study is to allow brand marketers and retailers to evaluate working relationships with agencies on 13 criteria and to let agencies evaluate working relationships with brand marketers on 13 criteria, as well.
This year we had 990 usable surveys — up 224 from 766 in 2011, or up 29 percent! That’s great! This speaks to the attention being given to shopper marketing in the industry. Brand marketers and retailers named 153 agencies while agencies named 144 different brand marketers … read >>
May 3, 2012 Comments
Dollar General Markets
Rick Dreiling says the secret of a successful small store is to focus on the items that drive most of the sales at bigger stores, reports Ann Zimmerman in the Wall Street Journal (4/30/12). Rick is chief executive of Dollar General Inc., and that’s his plan as he introduces “fresh food and more refrigerated products” at Dollar General Market stores. The hope is that the grocery items “will drive shoppers to visit more frequently — and increase how much they spend on standard dollar-store fare, from corn chips to clothing.”
The idea is to offer “a place where harried, frugal shoppers can get the most essential things they need at a discount without traipsing through airplane-hangar-sized supercenters, which top 150,000 square feet.” Bucking convention, “the company decided to put frequently purchased items such a bread, milk and juice by the store’s entrance for quick pickup. Most supermarkets stock these items far from the door, forcing customers to walk past an array of tempting merchandise.”
The new format, at 16,000 square feet is “far smaller” than that of supercenters “but still about twice the size of a typical dollar store. Over the next year, Dollar General plans to open about 40 of the Markets, many in ‘food deserts’ — neighborhoods that lack easy access to fresh food.” The Dollar General Market stores are not yet as profitable as the traditional stores, but Rick is optimistic. “They are a good opportunity for growth where they fit,” he says. “But we’re trying to be analytical and thoughtful, eating the elephant one bite at a time instead of swallowing the whole thing.”
May 1, 2012 Comments
The Pumping Station
Offering advice to nursing moms is enabling a small retailer to compete against Target, Babies R Us and Amazon, reports Nicole LaPorte in the New York Times (4/15/12). The Pump Station and Nurtury, a boutique in Santa Monica, California, began in 1986 as a pump-rental and consulting service for nursing moms. Wendy Haldeman and Corky Harvey initially ran the business out of their homes, but moved to an office after “their husbands became tired of panicked women knocking on their doors at 2 a.m. with nursing questions.” Today, the Pump Station offers a wide array of products for moms, each of which Wendy and Corky have checked out and approved. They also offer classes and private consultations for nursing moms.
The concept is certainly on trend: “According to the most recent information available from the Federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 75 percent of babies in the United States were nursed at birth in 2008, compared with 70 percent in 2000. Nursing is particularly popular with the Pump Station’s biggest demographic: white, college-educated women over 30.” The baby products market has also grown rapidly over the past decade “into a $9.8 billion” industry, and the “avalanche of baby care products” has left “many parents bewildered.” The confusion is not helped by the internet, which “can be cluttered with conflicting information on sleep training and other baby care methods.”
Nor is it necessarily solved by big, retail chains. “When someone is sitting here going, ‘Oh my God, there are 20,000 bottles out there,’ we can tell them, ‘But this bottle is going to be fabulous and will allow Dad to feed the baby and you to go back to work,” says Pump Station chief operating officer Cheryl Petran, a former buyer for Target. Cheryl says that “hundreds of years ago” women discussed nursing “by the campfire,” but that’s no longer an option. “So moms come here,” she says, “and it is the proverbial campfire, where you can talk and share … That’s a part you’re not going to get sitting in an aisle at Target.”
April 18, 2012 Comments
Eco Shoppers
Because shoppers are averse to paying a “green premium,” marketers are re-framing energy efficiency as cool technology, reports Bryn Nelson in the New York Times (4/11/12). In other words, in addition to buying “a 60-inch television boasting killer picture quality, you may get extra satisfaction knowing that your engineering marvel consumes only as much energy as a 75-watt lightbulb … Newly honed pitches steeped in consumer psychology are linking up the traits people crave — cutting-edge quality, say, or convenience — with the energy savings and reduced emissions championed by environmentalists.”
Whirlpool learned this lesson the hard way back in 1994 with its Energy Wise refrigerator “which created the impression that buying one entailed a sacrifice.” The brand did better with its “sharply styled and high efficient Duet frontload washer, introduced in 2001, which “allowed a large capacity, washed more thoroughly than a top-loader and was gentler on clothes.” The larger story is how such appliances affect energy consumption in aggregate.” The Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance, for example, “says that a regionwide shift to high-efficiency televisions could yield enough energy savings to power more than 290,000 homes each year.”
With this in mind, the alliance in 2008 started the Energy Forward initiative, which involved placing special labels on televisions meeting certain energy-efficiency standards and offering “a financial incentive of $5 to $15″ to retailers carrying the sets. The idea is to frame “efficiency” as another feature of a well-engineered television. So far, the initiative has “saved the region enough energy to power more than 10,000 homes for a year,” according to the alliance.” In a separate campaign, the alliance is promoting “ductless home heat pumps that double as air conditioners.” While the pumps save an estimated “25 to 50 percent on heating costs, the primary pitch has been to comfort and convenience.”
April 16, 2012 Comments
Sandbox Bliss
Advertising and shopper agencies must learn to play by new rules. By Chris Hoyt. To help provide its readers with direction in 2012 and beyond, The Hub Magazine ran a survey last December to ferret out what product marketers and their agencies think will be the key functions and skill sets that agencies will need to help their clients achieve their objectives over the next five years.
The premise: As product marketers increase their focus on path-to-purchase marketing, the functions and expectations of agencies have shifted — for both advertising and shopper-marketing agencies. Given this, the survey focused on developing answers to the following:
What do current practitioners think the respective roles of these agencies should be in terms of planning, media development and promotion development in a path-to-purchase environment? What obstacles are seen for each type of agency in performing these functions? What are the areas of potential conflict — i.e., in which segment of the path-to-purchase is the battle occurring? How do these practitioners — again, defined as both product marketers and agencies — envision the ideal working relationship? … read >>
April 9, 2012 Comments





